HouseStay has supported families seeking flexible, temporary housing solutions. For job relocations, snowbirds, and military reassignments, Shelter Island has been a reliable destination for those needing a comfortable place to land.
In recent months, we’ve listed 1 fully furnished rentals, including 1 house. These properties were equipped with amenities like Full Kitchen, Family Friendly, and Smoke Detector—perfect for creating a space that truly felt like home. Many rentals also included convenient utilities such as Gas, Heat, and WiFi.
The average monthly rent for a 6 bedroom / 7 bath House in Shelter Island has hovered around $30,483, giving future renters a helpful benchmark as they plan ahead. If you like Shelter Island, consider checking out nearby properties in Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton, East Hampton, Southampton, and Old Lyme, where similar family friendly monthly housing options may be available. Our listings are always being updated, so be sure to check back soon for new opportunities in Shelter Island!
HouseStay has featured a variety of homes that offered the perfect blend of comfort, style, and relaxation. From houses, these properties were thoughtfully curated to feel like a true vacation retreat.
Vacationers have enjoyed 1 unique properties located in the Shelter Island neighborhoods, close to popular attractions and entertainment options. Each home was equipped with amenities designed to elevate the leisure experience—like A/C (Central Air), Full Kitchen, and Family Friendly for added comfort.
Utility packages often included essentials like Heat, Trash Pick Up, and Gas, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable extended stay for travelers. With average monthly pricing for a 6 bedroom / 7 bath rental around $30,483, guests were able to plan memorable getaways that fit a variety of group sizes and budgets.
Nearby cities like Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton, East Hampton, Southampton, and Old Lyme may offer similar monthly vacation housing options. Our inventory updates regularly, so check back soon for a stylish and stress-free extended stay in Shelter Island.
HouseStay Guarantee
We perform in-depth background checks on Host and Tenants to create a community everyone can trust.
Roommate Free
HouseStay only offers entire accommodations. We don’t offer spare rooms or shared spaces.
Fully Furnished
All accommodations listed on HouseStay are fully furnished and include all utilities in the monthly rate.
Month-to-Month Flexibility
Not sure how long you’ll be staying? All listings are available for a minimum of 30 nights with no maximum.
Shelter Island, New York, is a hidden gem that offers a peaceful and tranquil ambiance, making it the perfect city to book an extended stay furnished rental. With its charming neighborhoods like Dering Harbor and Shelter Island Heights, residents can enjoy a sense of community while still being surrounded by natural beauty. The city is also located near popular attractions such as Mashomack Preserve and Sylvester Manor Educational Farm, providing endless opportunities for outdoor activities and exploration.
For families looking to relocate, Shelter Island is an ideal choice due to its top-rated schools like Shelter Island School and proximity to neighboring cities like Greenport and Sag Harbor. Vacationers will love the serene beaches and picturesque parks the city has to offer, while digital nomads will appreciate the ease of finding monthly short-term rentals with all the necessary amenities. Business travelers and interns can take advantage of the city’s close proximity to major hospitals like Stony Brook Southampton Hospital and entertainment professionals will enjoy easy access to popular museums and shopping areas.
Medical tourists seeking temporary housing during a surgery or medical procedure will find comfort in the city’s peaceful setting and convenient location. Students looking for fully furnished month-to-month rentals will appreciate the city’s vibrant community and access to nearby colleges like Stony Brook University. Additionally, insurance housing for individuals in need of temporary relocation due to disaster recovery can find a sense of security in Shelter Island’s welcoming atmosphere. Travel nurses, sports professionals, and entertainment professionals will also benefit from the city’s close-knit community and array of amenities for a comfortable extended stay.